Best Eyebrow Pencil 2021 – UK Buyer’s Guide

An eyebrow pencil is probably the first and the most crucial make-up item most young women buy to make themselves look more sophisticated and older than they are. Drawing on those eyebrows adds confidence and gives them drive. Many ladies won’t leave the house without their eyebrow pencil. Choosing make-up is an important job in a woman’s life and they want to be sure to get the best eyebrow kit.

UK Eyebrow Pencil Buyers Guide

Applying the right eyebrow pencil is key to your overall look. It frames your face and enhances the appearance of the rest of your make-up. Although eyebrow pencils are easy to apply, they are the very devil to master and patience is often required, even with the best eyebrow pencil UK, to build your skills and achieve the look you want.

Pencils are just one of many types of products on sale for the brows. But they are difficult to beat. After all, you have handled pencils since you were a small child. But how do you find a pencil that meets your requirements? A good eyebrow pencil will enable you to create a natural look or create sexy sultry eyebrows for that special date. It is all in the sharpening. Do you want a stubby point that gives broad lines, or do you use a brush with an acute point that enables you to build your brows through a series of narrow strokes? Or do you dispense with sharpening altogether and go for a retractable nib?

The adage “you get what you pay for” usually rings true. Paying a lot of money for a pencil doesn’t necessarily mean it will perform better than a cheaper one, although there is a high probability it will. Remember though, famous brand names carry a premium. There are some super products available at very reasonable prices, so cheap in fact that you can buy more than one and experiment.

Some women need only one good black eyebrow pencil which they use skillfully to create eyebrows that complement their colouring and outfit. Blondes and redheads may prefer a pencil that is formulated to suit them and if this is you, there are lots of pencils on the market tailored to your needs. Whatever your hair colour, there is of course, nothing to stop you owning more than one pencil and in a variety of different colours.

If you carry your eyebrow pencil about with you, choose one that will easily fit into a handbag or purse. There are even some dinky ones around that will slip easily into a jacket pocket.

You also need to consider whether you want a waterproof product. This may cost you a little more and be sure to buy the best waterproof eyebrow pencil you can afford. It will be worth it, particularly if you want to cry in the cinema at the latest chic flick or you get caught in a sudden shower and it will save you the embarrassment of black running down your face.

Vegan based products and products not tested on animals together with dermatologically tested pencils may be things you look for when buying make-up. All of these are all readily available on the high street.

When you are looking for an eyebrow pencil do you go to the concession booths at your local department store and get advice on the latest products from make-up professionals? Do you just buy off the shelf? Or maybe you order from catalogues or over the internet. All those ways are fine, although it must be said that if you are buying a product for the first time, there is no substitute for being able to see it and handle it for yourself.

That’s about all the buyer guidance you need to go out and buy the best eyebrow products. Below is a list of popular ones and there is something for everyone.

Eyebrow Pencil Product Reviews

Rimmel Eyebrow Pencil, Dark Brown by Rimmel

When black just doesn’t suit your colouring or give you the look you want, this brown pencil from Rimmel may be just what you are looking for to give shape and style to your eyebrows. Buyers of this long wear product love the brow styling brush that comes with the eyebrow pencil. Some eye pencils are sticky. Not this one. It applies easily giving immediate definition to eyebrows. The pencil has undergone ophthalmological testing which confirmed it is safe on the eyes.

Check Price Now

JaneDream Double Head Eyebrow Pencil Waterproof Automatic Eyeliner Pen

This double automatic rotation pencil is the eyewear solution for busy women everywhere. Its compactness takes nothing away from the stylish design and it will easily slip into a purse or handbag. Five colours are offered, black, brown, grey, light coffee and dark coffee. There is a good chance that if you try one colour you will be so pleased with it that you will soon be ordering another. Once the pencil has been applied, you are set up for the day, even if that involves a swim or heavy rain, because the product is waterproof.

Check Price Now

Rimmel Soft Kohl Kajal Professional Eyeliner Pencil, Jet Black

If you want to achieve that sexy smokey-eyed look this professional pencil from Rimmel will make it possible. It is easy to apply and doesn’t drag or tug, so it’s great for those with sensitive skin. The colour is a dense black which easily fills gaps and leaves a very smooth finish. Rimmel challenges you to get the London Look and there is no doubt, this product will help. In no time you can create a smudged appearance that will last for up to 12 hours.

Check Price Now

Maybelline Brow Satin Medium Brown

The clever design of this Maybelline product puts a gel pencil at one end and filling powder at the other. It is easy to use and gives results fast. The colour is a versatile medium brown which means, no matter what coloured hair you have, you can sculpt full and luscious brows and plug any gaps with the filling powder. Even if you have thin eyebrows or ones that aren’t prominent, this product will plump them out and produce a look you will be delighted with. It is probably the best eyebrow pencil for sparse brows.

Check Price Now

Eylure Firm Brow Pencil, Mid Brown

Eyelure is on to a sure winner with this brow pencil. It has a traditional point at one end and a styling brush at the opposite end. By using pencil and brush you can quickly build colour and depth until you get the finish you want. This is also a nourishing and conditioning product, so each time you use it your brows benefit from the rosemary oil, vitamin E and RepHair it contains. There are four shades available to suit all hair colouring.

Check Price Now

Trillycoler Waterproof Automatic Rotated Makeup Eyebrow Pen Eyeline Pencil + Brush (Dark Coffee)

Trillycoler certainly knows a thing or two about what women want when it comes to eye make-up. This is a double automatic rotation pencil which comes with a styling brush at the opposite end to the pencil point. It’s easy to apply and once on it will stay on for many hours. It is waterproof too, so no need to worry about downpours. Despite its long-lasting ability, you will find it easy to remove at the end of the day.

Check Price Now

Maxdona Waterproof Retractable Long-Lasting Eyebrow Eye Brow Black Case Chalk Pen Pencil light brown

Maxdona certainly caused a stir in the market when they launched this chalk eyebrow pencil. Its design takes in the latest innovations and the product is specially shaped for precision, making it not only easy to apply but capable of quickly producing the look you want. This product often finds its way into the box of professional make-up artists which should give you the confidence to know that you are investing in the very best.

Check Price Now

Revlon Colorstay Brow Pencil, Soft Brown

Revlon has been a market leader in the make-up game for decades, so you can be assured of the quality of this product. This is one of the few eyebrow pencils available with a chip defiant formula. It comes with a brush applicator and once applied will set your defined brows in 30 seconds. Revlon is rightly proud of their rich colour palette and the soft brown of this pencil will give you a luxuriant finish.

Check Price Now

Barry M Cosmetics Brow Wow, Light/Medium

This attractive looking pencil comes from the increasingly popular Barry M and is part of the creative Brow Wow range. The product is free from animal testing. By following the line of the hair with short feathery strokes you can quickly and easy add shape and depth to your eyebrows, filling any gaps as you go. The pencil provides a light to medium finish which makes it great for day wear but equally suitable for that special evening out.

Check Price Now


I have just taken you through some of the best eyebrow pencils available on the market today. Like all great tools, they are simple and uncomplicated and once you learn to use them properly, you can achieve great results. Even the more expensive ones can be purchased for a lot less than a king’s ransom. There is no replacement for a good eyebrow pencil. It will last you and you will certainly get value for money from it. Good hunting!

Read next: The Best UK Beauty Box